{ subscribe_url:'/share/sites/library-of-congress-blogs/insights-kluge-center.php', }

Lincoln and the Supreme Court

We should think about the Supreme Court not as a separate and isolated institution, but rather as an integral and interconnected part of the federal political apparatus in the 19th century.

–Rachel Shelden

In her lecture “Abraham Lincoln, the U.S. Supreme Court, and the Politics of Slavery“, historian Rachel Shelden examined Lincoln’s relationship with the Supreme Court. The lecture is now available on the Kluge Center’s website and YouTube playlist.

Shelden is working on a political history of the U.S. Supreme Court in the Civil War and Reconstruction eras, from roughly the 1830s to the 1890s. Sources and evidence in the Library of Congress demonstrate that the Court was an inherently political body during this period. Justices’ political behavior influenced their engagement with important issues, including slavery.

As a Senate candidate in 1858, Lincoln indicted Chief Justice Roger Taney in a conspiracy to spread slavery throughout the United States through the Court’s decision in Dred Scott v. Sanford. Whether Lincoln actually believed this accusation is still up for debate; there was political benefit to making such a charge. However the notion that this was implausible because the Court was simply a legal body deciding cases independent of politics turns out to be historically inaccurate. In fact, Lincoln knew then, and we know now, that the Court was intimately connected to other branches of government. As Shelden says in her lecture, “There were no stark lines separating senators from justices or even judge from lawyer.” Supreme Court Justices and Congressmen interacted professionally and socially on a continual basis in Washington, and lawyers in the antebellum period also tended to develop intimate relationships with Justices. So even though the Dred Scott conspiracy may not have happened, it certainly was possible that it could have happened. Perhaps Lincoln was telling the truth after all?

Click below to hear Shelden’s lecture on the subject

Rachel Shelden is Assistant Professor of American History at The University of Oklahoma. She is the author of “Washington Brotherhood: Politics, Social Life, & the Coming of the Civil War” and is working on a forthcoming political history of the Supreme Court. In 2015, she was a Kluge Fellow at The John W. Kluge Center.

Law, Religion, and Liberty: A Conversation with John Witte, Jr.

Members of the Scholars Council are appointed by the Librarian of Congress to advise on matters related to scholarship at the Library, with special attention to the Kluge Center and the Kluge Prize. The Council includes distinguished scholars, writers, researchers, and scientists. “Insights” is featuring some of the work of this highly-accomplished group of thinkers. […]

Re-Imagining the Amazon

If you think about the way people occupied space then and think about the way people occupy space now, we might be able to come up with better strategies for managing the Amazon. –Anna Browne Ribeiro In her lecture “Imagining the Amazon, European Colonialism and the Making of Modern Day Amazonia“, geoarchaeologist Anna Browne Ribeiro […]

A Conversation with Author and Literature Scholar Peter Brooks

A 2016 distinguished visiting scholar at the Library of Congress, comparative literature scholar Peter Brooks is writing and researching a new book on how novels relate to history and societal self-understanding, drawing in particular on Flaubert’s novel, “Sentimental Education.” At the Library of Congress, he has been using the collections of the European Reading Room […]

One Year Ago Today…

It is with fond memories that we remember this day last year, when we began to welcome back more than 100 former scholars to the Kluge Center for our first-ever #ScholarFest. Through its first 15 years the Kluge Center supported and showcased exceptional scholarship by more than 1,000 scholars and invited speakers. #ScholarFest was our […]

EU Month of Culture Spotlight: Ireland

As part of the European Month of Culture in May 2016, we focus on scholars from European Union member states who have conducted research at The John W. Kluge Center at the Library of Congress. Wish to apply for a fellowship at the Library? Applications are now being accepted for Kluge Fellowships. Scholars worldwide who […]

EU Month of Culture Spotlight: Spain

As part of the European Month of Culture in May 2016, we focus on scholars from European Union member states who have conducted research at The John W. Kluge Center at the Library of Congress. Wish to apply for a fellowship at the Library? Applications are now being accepted for Kluge Fellowships. Scholars worldwide who […]

EU Month of Culture Spotlight: Sweden

As part of this year’s European Month of Culture, we focus on scholars from European Union member states who have conducted research at the Library of Congress Kluge Center. Wish to apply for a fellowship at the Library? Applications are now being accepted for Kluge Fellowships. Scholars worldwide who have earned a terminal advanced degree […]