{ subscribe_url: '/share/sites/library-of-congress-blogs/law.php' }

Courtroom Sketches

Ruby

Brodie, H. (1964) Ruby trial, Dallas / Howard Brodie. Prints and Photographs Division, Library of Congress.

Though courtroom drawings in the United States reportedly go back to the Salem Witch Trials, the idea of sketch artists in the courtroom has fluctuated in popularity within the judicial branch, at times tolerated, at other times banned, from the proceedings.

Courtroom artists are in no way affiliated with the legal system. They are usually freelance artists or may work for a news outlet or other media publication.

This art form exists to provide the public with a visual record of court proceedings that we otherwise would not have.

Stans

Kenny, A. (1974) Mitchell Stans trial / Aggie Whelan Kenny. Thomas V. Girardi Collection. Prints and Photographs Division, Library of Congress.

With the advent of modern photography came the debate on whether to allow cameras in the courtroom.  Some courts have permitted them, though many jurisdictions, especially federal courts, ban them as being too intrusive.

In fact, Rule 53 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure states that, “Except as otherwise provided by a statute or these rules, the court must not permit the taking of photographs in the courtroom during judicial proceedings or the broadcasting of judicial proceedings from the courtroom.”

More recently, Supreme Court Chief Justice John Roberts has stated that: “There’s a concern (among justices) about the impact of television on the functioning of the institution. We’re going to be very careful before we do anything that might have an adverse impact.”

Madoff

Williams, E. (2009) Bernard Madoff, going to jail post plea / E. Williams. Thomas V. Girardi Collection. Prints and Photographs Division, Library of Congress.

Church, M. (1992) John Gotti trial / Marilyn Church. [Image] Retrieved from the Library of Congress

Church, M. (1992) John Gotti trial / Marilyn Church. Prints and Photographs Division, Library of Congress.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Thus, even in these days of Instagram, Periscope and the like, courtroom sketches are still the primary mode of reporting many judicial proceedings, giving the public a glimpse of the setting, mood and reactions of the various players in a trial. But they too can be banned or at least restricted by order of the judge, for example in cases involving minors, to protect jurors, or in other situations when the judge feels that such renderings could hurt the proceedings.

The Prints and Photographs Division of the Library of Congress has been fortunate to obtain several significant collections of such drawings, making the Library’s holdings the most comprehensive in any American institution. The latest acquisition is the “Thomas V. Girardi Collection of Courtroom Illustration Drawings”. This collection contains 96 sketches from notable cases over the past five decades, such as the Charles Manson and O. J. Simpson trials.  Included are works by Aggie Kenny, Bill Robles and Elizabeth Williams.

Manson

Robles, W. T. (1970) [Charles Manson on the witness stand / B. Robles]. Thomas V. Girardi Collection. Prints and Photographs Division, Library of Congress.

Previous acquisitions have included the works of Marilyn Church and Howard Brodie.

Your chance to see some of these works in person is coming soon.  The Prints & Photographs Division of the Library of Congress is launching an exhibit of courtroom illustrations next year.  And the Law Library will have a hand in the display.  Items from our collection will provide value-added content through copies of court decisions and briefs filed in some of the high profile cases that will be depicted.

So keep reading our blog as well as Picture This (the blog for Prints and Photographs) and the Library’s website for more information on this exhibit and courtroom art.

 

 

 

The Rehabilitation of Dante Alighieri, Seven Centuries Later

The following is a guest post by Dante Figueroa, a senior legal information analyst at the Law Library of Congress. Dante has contributed a number of In Custodia Legis blog posts, including on Resources and Treasures of the Italian Parliamentary Libraries,  Legislation Protecting Italian Cultural Heritage, and Proposed Anti-Sect Legislation in Italy: An Ongoing Debate. On December […]

World Health Day

This is a guest post by Constance Johnson, a senior legal research analyst at the Law Library of Congress.  Constance has previously written on Water Rights on Star Island, Law Relating to Refugee Rights – Global Legal Collection Highlights, and most recently on her summer vacation on Star Island. April 7, 2016, is World Health […]

Becoming the Plutarch of Renaissance Lawyers

Quid sit quod multi vitas principum and ducum… diligentissime conscripserint atque inde genus hoc scribendi profectum, paulatim ad eos homines pervenerit, qui leniores quodammodo virtutes profitentur, Philosophos dico, Medicos, Oratores, Poetas… donec ad Rhetores ac Grammaticos deventum est, nemo adhuc extiterit, qui sibi Legumlatorum et Iurisprudentum vitas in argumentum iusti et peculiaris operis desumpserit… How […]

Manuscript Waste Bindings at the Library of Congress – Pic of the Week

In this week’s pic of the week post, we catch up with Library of Congress employee Dan Paterson, who is a senior rare book conservator in the Conservation Section of the Library’s Conservation Division. Since 2013, Dan has been surveying book bindings in the Library’s special collections, looking for bindings that incorporate manuscript waste. Manuscript […]

A Founding Father is Born on March 16, 1751

Today the Library of Congress is commemorating the 265th anniversary of James Madison’s birth. Madison, the fourth president of the United States, was born on March 16, 1751 in the Colony of Virginia. The Library’s James Madison Memorial Building serves as the national memorial to James Madison. The building was approved by an act of […]

On the Shelf: Minnesota Session Laws

This installment of On the Shelf features the Session Laws of the State of Minnesota. The title caught my attention when technicians inventorying and reviewing it brought up several questions (leading to one incorrect answer on my part). The initial question was in reference to the first three volumes which had a different title than […]

Anniversary of the Radio Act of 1927, The Beginning of Broadcast Regulation

As new technologies emerge, the federal government works to ratchet up its regulations. If the technology is sufficiently pervasive, the government creates regulatory arms for it. Radio is one of the earlier examples of this cycle of technological innovation and its regulation. Before 1927, the Commerce Department regulated radio, but the department’s control over the […]

Tribute to Justice Antonin Scalia — Pic of the Week

In tribute to Justice Antonin Scalia’s life and commitment to the rule of law, this pic of the week features Justice Scalia at the Library’s Magna Carta evening gala. Justice Scalia was a monumental legal thinker, who was known for his deep reverence of the United States Constitution, exuberant personality, and interest in opera. Therefore, it probably does […]