Tragedy and Transformation: Looking at San Francisco’s Chinatown with Primary Sources

This post is by Rebecca Newland, the current Library of Congress Teacher in Residence.

On Wednesday, April 18, 1906, an earthquake struck San Francisco. Much of the city, including its Chinese immigration enclave, Chinatown, was destroyed by tremors and fires. While this was a devastating tragedy, it was also an opportunity to rebuild and renew. Below is a series of photographs from the Library’s Prints and Photographs collections that offers a path for student engagement with San Francisco’s pre- and post-earthquake Chinatown.

San Francisco, Calif. – China Town, Sacramento St., 1866 http://hdl.loc.gov/loc.pnp/cph.3a21524

Chinatown2

The Heart of Chinatown, San Francisco, Cal., c. 1906 http://hdl.loc.gov/loc.pnp/det.4a13265

Without revealing the location, offer the photograph San Francisco, Calif. – China Town, Sacramento St., 1866. Support interaction with the picture with the Library’s primary source analysis tool and questions selected from the Analyzing Photographs and Prints Teacher’s Guide. Invite students to speculate on when and where this was created. After disclosing the title, revisit the photograph. Deepen student engagement by asking: What details in the photo help to identify the location and time period?

Move next to The Heart of Chinatown, San Francisco, Cal., c. 1906, taken after the earthquake. Ask again for students to identify details that indicate when and where this was taken. At this point, students may be eager to find out more about the earthquake and its effect on the inhabitants of San Francisco and Chinatown.

Provide this short article from the Library’s historic newspaper collection, Chronicling America, discussing the hardships suffered by residents of Chinatown after the earthquake. Prompt discussion by asking:

  • Who do you think was the audience for this article?
  • What can you tell about the point of view of the creators?
  • What questions do you have after reading the article?

Push the conversation a step further with this photograph of Chinatown from 1929.

Chinatown3

In the heart of modern Chinatown, San Francisco, Calif., 1929 http://hdl.loc.gov/loc.pnp/cph.3b44570

 

Ask:

  • What details in the photo help to identify the location and time period?
  • What differences are there between this and the 1866 photograph?
  • What is the importance of the earthquake in the development of Chinatown?
  • What surprises you about the rebuilding of Chinatown?

Ask students to look at the three photos together to begin to construct the story about the evolution of Chinatown as a place of residence as well as commerce and tourism.

  • What additional information do we need to understand the evolution of Chinatown from 1866-1929 and beyond?
  • Where should we look for this information?

Are there areas in your own state or community that have changed radically over the years? What resources exist in the community to investigate these changes?

Wanted: Teachers to Serve as the Library of Congress Teacher-in-Residence During the 2015-16 Academic Year

Since 2000, the Library of Congress has recruited teachers to work with Educational Outreach staff to help teachers incorporate the Library’s collection of over 16 million digitized primary sources into high-quality instruction. Previous Teachers-in-Residence have led professional development workshops for teachers in Washington, DC, and across the United States. They have represented the Library at various conferences and meetings and developed teaching materials and lessons that use the Library’s digitized primary sources for national distribution. We are now recruiting for teachers in residence for the 2015-2016 academic year.

Clara Barton’s Papers at the Library of Congress: Personalizing Women’s History Month

This blog post comes courtesy of Rebecca Newland, the current teacher-in-residence at the Library of Congress. To make Women’s History Month come alive, consider focusing on the life and works of individual women from United States history. The Library of Congress collections include the suffrage scrapbooks of Elizabeth Smith Miller and her daughter, Anne Fitzhugh […]

Teacher Webinar February 24, 4 pm: Free Primary Sources from the World Digital Library

“Imagine giving your students free, unlimited access to treasures from cultural institutions from around the world. Perhaps your students would examine an ancient manuscript up close for small but important details. Afterward, they might learn more about its significance from an expert, or search for additional items from the same time or place.” The World […]

Teacher Webinar with Teaching Tolerance, Thursday February 19: Building Literacy Skills and Teaching about the Civil Rights Movement

The Civil Rights Act of 1964, the conditions that led to it and its legacy are the subjects of a four-part webinar series. Co-facilitated by education experts from Teaching Tolerance and the Library of Congress, the series will invite participants to examine unique primary sources from the Library’s collections that illuminate the laws and practices […]

Primary Sources and Social Justice: A New Article in Teaching Tolerance Magazine

A black flag emblazoned with stark white letters that read, “A MAN WAS LYNCHED YESTERDAY.” A newspaper article written by a suffragist on hunger strike describing being force-fed by her jailers. Photographs of weary children on a poster underneath the title “Nearly Two Million Child Workers Under Sixteen Years To-day.” What do these items have […]