{ subscribe_url:'//blogs.loc.gov/share/sites/library-of-congress-blogs/folklife.php' }

War in Paradise: Navy Veterans of the Pacific Theater, Part II

The following is the second of a two-part guest post by Joseph Patton, a Library of Congress Junior Fellow working with the Veterans History Project this summer.

Photograph of Nathaniel Duberstein in uniform, 1941. Nathaniel Duberstein Collection, Veterans History Project (AFC2001/001/74627).

Last week, I shared with you three stories from the Veterans History Project (VHP) collections of World War II Navy veterans who served in the Pacific theater of operations. Of those veterans, two lost their lives before reuniting with their families. The other sustained injuries, but survived nonetheless. Each shows a unique aspect of the human elements of war. And still there are others.

While listening to the oral history of Harrison Chilton, I made an interesting discovery. Chilton was a Mississippi-born pilot serving in Fighting Squadron 1 (VF-1). Throughout his interview, he provided a detailed chronology of his experiences and the men with whom he flew. As I listened, I thought I heard a familiar name, and upon further investigation realized that one of the squadron mates of whom he was speaking was the same man whose diaries were on the desk right next to me. New Jersey native Nathaniel Norman Duberstein was another pilot in VF-1, and his collection is one of my favorites. It contains photographs, poems, and beautiful diaries of his experiences, one of which was actually written in a blank Japanese ledger book he found on the island of Tarawa.

The comparison between these two men is a wonderful example of the facts of history meeting the humanity of individual service. The Battle of the Philippine Sea on June 19-20, 1944 is legendary in the annals of naval and air warfare. The U.S. Navy inflicted tremendous damage upon the Japanese with very few losses to their enemy. Chilton recalled the events decades later in his oral history, providing a very detailed account of his experiences. To supplement his recollections, on June 19, 1944, Duberstein wrote in his diary, “The boys have done a good job and stopped most of the Jap ships. God damn, this had better make the front page!” Together these two collections provide a complete recounting of the battle. As Chilton speaks of what happened years later, Duberstein is able to talk about how he felt right there on the day of the action. We remember the Battle of the Philippine Sea, but they recall what they did and how they felt on a particular Tuesday in June, 1944, before it was the stuff of legend.

IMG_0733

Page from photograph album compiled by James D. Mayhew. Veterans History Project (AFC2001/001/77988).

Perhaps the VHP collection that best demonstrates the idea of the human element of war is that of James Mayhew, an Oklahoman who joined the Navy in 1943 and was assigned to the battleship USS New Mexico (BB-40). Mayhew wrote constantly to his mother and grandmother; his letters, filled with sketches and notes written by his buddies, illustrate the camaraderie and companionship that shipmates often form. Even more striking is the photograph scrapbook within his collection. Upon one page are images of USO shows and beautiful Pacific sunsets, and right next to them are scenes of horror and the aftermath of battle. An image of the shipmates sunbathing on the deck is set next to another photo of men clearing a shore road of scorched Japanese corpses. To Mayhew, the juxtaposition of these contrasting images makes sense and tells his story. With these powerful images, Mayhew’s collection, in particular, captures something of the humanity within the history of warfare.

During my short tenure here at VHP, I’ve read and listened to the collections of many World War II Pacific theater veterans. However, in early July, I got the opportunity to speak with one in person when he visited the Library of Congress. Samuel Culotta was a Maryland native who enlisted in 1942 at the age of 17. Soon after he volunteered to be a medical corpsman, he went ashore with the Marines and was involved in some of the bitterest campaigns of the conflict. Armed with only a handgun and medical bag, he tended to the wounded in the thick of battle often risking his own life to save those of his comrades. Before speaking to all in attendance he stated, “Let me begin by saying this. The Japanese were cruel. The Japanese were cruel and we were too. We learned to be cruel.” As he continued his stories, he spoke of good times and bad. There was laughter and there were tears. Most striking though were the feelings he still had for these events, 70 years later. He spoke of his Navy career, citing dates and places that I knew well from my studies, but this was more than a history lesson. Samuel Culotta’s experiences, and those of all these veterans, show us the role of the individual within great events. These stories all demonstrate the humanity within the history.

To access more collections from those who served from World War I through the more recent conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan, visit the Veterans History Project’s website, www.loc.gov/vets.

3 Comments

  1. JAG
    July 22, 2015 at 8:38 am

    I believe the “sunbathing” picture in Mayhew’s book is likely a line-crossing ceremony. It was typically done when crossing the international date line, but also for the equator. It looks like the sailors are putting some soldiers or Marines through the ceremony. They often got a card or certificate, as well. Your point, of course, still stands. This was typically a comical, fun ceremony – a sharp contrast to the picture opposite.

  2. Megan Harris
    July 23, 2015 at 1:38 pm

    Thanks so much for your comment! Yes, you are absolutely correct, and Mayhew includes additional photographs of the line-crossing ceremonies in the book. The “sunbathing” image mentioned in the post is also positioned next to the “road-clearing” photo, but on the adjacent page that is not visible within the scrapbook image here, unfortunately. As you said though, it still shows that sharp contrast that Mayhew found natural.

  3. H. R. Chilton, Jr.
    July 29, 2015 at 5:02 pm

    Thank you, Mr. Patton, for giving your attention to the materials in the VHP collection from my father and others. Like many, as you note, my father’s feelings about the war were mixed. War is ugly. But his feelings about the squadron were not. In 2007, my wife and I were able to attend the last reunion of VF-1 with him, held on board the U.S.S. Yorktown, now permanently moored at Charleston, South Carolina. The Ready Room was outfitted with the squadron roster and other memorabilia. This was the ship they flew from during the Battle of the Philippine Sea. Those men were still very close. They remembered all the stories, and their stories were at the center of who they knew themselves to be, and I think for my father and Mr. Duberstein especially, their memories of the war made them deeply human, utterly committed to justice and decency and compassion. So again, thanks. Let’s us now carry those stories in our memory together.

Add a Comment

This blog is governed by the general rules of respectful civil discourse. You are fully responsible for everything that you post. The content of all comments is released into the public domain unless clearly stated otherwise. The Library of Congress does not control the content posted. Nevertheless, the Library of Congress may monitor any user-generated content as it chooses and reserves the right to remove content for any reason whatever, without consent. Gratuitous links to sites are viewed as spam and may result in removed comments. We further reserve the right, in our sole discretion, to remove a user's privilege to post content on the Library site. Read our Comment and Posting Policy.

Required fields are indicated with an * asterisk.