{ subscribe_url: '/share/sites/library-of-congress-blogs/law.php' }

National Skip the Straw Day: Pioneers in Disappearing Plastic Straws

Paper vs. Plastic Straws [Photo by Geraldine Dávila González]

Tomorrow is National Skip the Straw Day and while all around the Washington, D.C., people are skipping the straw or switching to non-plastic straws, it made me wonder about the current straw laws in the U.S., especially here in D.C., and how we got to this point.

Throughout its history, the straw has received countless makeovers, but I was curious: how was the straw created in the first place? According to the Smithsonian Institution’s Lemelson Center for the Study of Invention and Innovation, the original design for the modern straw, which was designed to be made out of paper, was patented by a D.C. native, Marvin Stone on January 3, 1888. Stalks of rye grass were used prior to the invention of the straw, and that annoyed Stone since it left residues in his drink. Later, in 1937, Joseph B. Friedman, after seeing his daughter struggling to drink a milkshake, patented a design for the “bendy” straw. The paper straw ruled the market in the 1960s until it was discovered that plastic straws were more durable and made for a more pleasant drinking experience, leading to the paper straw being phased out completely by the 1970s. Historically, the straw has shape-shifted into consumer-appealing forms like the “Krazy Straw,” a staple at fun parties and events, and the “Magic Straw,” which contained a filter for depositing flavor into the drink. Some companies even created cereal straws, so people can drink their milk and eat their cereal, a two for one. However, these didn’t last long since humans are unable to eat and drink at the exact same time and were discontinued in 2009.

In comparison to proposed alternatives, the plastic disposable straw has reigned supreme. In fact, Americans go through 500 million straws a day.  However, these plastic straws are not recyclable and end up in our oceans, causing pollution and harming wildlife. Plastic straws account for about 4 percent of the plastic pollution found in oceans by volume, but less than 1 percent by weight, and plastic never decomposes, as it uses UV rays to break down into smaller pieces, never disappearing entirely. In attempt to address this environmental issue, Washington, D.C., decided to ban plastic straws altogether. This measure was implemented in January 2019, with D.C. following Seattle as one of the few U.S. cities to establish a plastic straw ban law. There is a phase-out period in place until July to make the transition to alternatives before the city begins imposing fines. Other cities with a plastic straw ban in place are Miami BeachMalibu, San Francisco, and St. Petersburg, Florida.

This isn’t the first environment-centered product restriction law established by D.C. It enacted a nickel tax on plastic bags in 2010 and banned plastic foam food containers in 2016.

As D.C. Department of Energy & Environment (DOEE) director Tommy Wells told the D.C. Council committee that considered the proposed straw law, “District businesses and organizations that serve or sell food or beverages must use compostable or reusable straws,” a classification that includes those made of paper, bamboo, hay, stainless steel, and glass. Consumers can also use purchased straws like the reusable alternatives being developed out of metals and glass, including a collapsible straw created for easy storage.

The ban on plastic straws directly affects people with disabilities, who may require a straw to drink. Mathew McCollough, director of D.C.’s Office of Disability Rights, testified that paper straws are more likely to break apart, rendering them unusable or creating a choking hazard. In addition, people with disabilities can severely injure themselves if they bite down hard on a metal or glass straw. “While the reduction of plastic straws for public consumption is a just and needed cause,” McCollough said, “the complete elimination of plastic straws from these entities neglects the legitimate needs of many DC residents and visitors.” One-pager states from DOEE states that they “recognize some customers with disabilities require plastic straws as a reasonable accommodation to consume food or beverages. Regulated entities must keep a limited stock of plastic straws available to meet these needs and remain compliant with local and federal disability rights laws.”

To implement these policies, Zach Rybarczyk from DOEE inspects D.C. restaurants to monitor compliance with the plastic-straw ban. Now known as the straw cop, Rybarczyk was seen patrolling Union Station, warning establishments about the length of their grace period and the amount of the fines in place if they keep distributing plastic straws.

Private companies are making an effort to eliminate plastic straws even if laws are not put into place in all cities. States like California and Hawaii have introduced proposals that would restrict their use, and cities like New York City, and Portland also have proposals in progress.

 

The Law Library of Congress Rare Book Curator Displays New Acquisitions – Pic of the Week

On February 12, 2019, Law Library Rare Book Curator Nathan Dorn joined colleagues from across the Library of Congress to showcase new treasures that the Library acquired over the past year. The Law Library’s new acquisitions that were on display included a land grant from William Penn, Harry Truman’s law school notebook, a document related […]

An Interview with Jane Sánchez, Law Librarian of Congress and Acting Deputy Librarian for Library Collections and Services

Can you tell us about you and about your career path leading to your current role(s)? I came to the Library of Congress in November of 2014, when I began as the Chief of the Humanities and Social Sciences Division.  I assumed the position of Law Librarian of Congress in February of 2017, and also […]

An Interview with Kelly McKenna, Program Specialist for the Office of External Relations

Describe your background. I grew up in West Chester, Pennsylvania, and lived in Ithaca, New York, while attending college. In 2011, I spent six months in Amsterdam, where I studied Dutch culture and took classes at the University of Amsterdam and the Gerrit Rietveld Academie. In 2012, I moved to Washington, D.C. where I lived […]

Congress.gov New, Tip, and Top for February 2019

In January, Robert announced the first version of the new Committee Schedule that we have been working on.  It is a great way to see quickly which meetings and hearings the House and Senate committees have scheduled for the week. New Enhancements for February 2019 You can find all of the Congress.gov Enhancements for February and […]

Interview with Geraldine Dávila González, Program Specialist for the Office of External Relations

Describe your background. I was born and raised in Carolina, Puerto Rico. I have a huge family on both sides from all across Puerto Rico, and we love to spend time together every time I go back. I graduated with my bachelor’s degree and immediately moved to Washington, D.C. in June 2017. Moving to Washington […]

Interview with Jolande Goldberg, Law Classification Specialist

Describe your background My first encounter with the Library of Congress (LC) was as a young German legal historian with a fellowship to research the transplantation of European law and government structures into the original American colonies, in particular New Netherlands (New York).  My chief adviser and director at the Heidelberg Academy of Sciences and […]

Villa Horion, Düsseldorf, Germany – Pic of the Week

In December 2018, I visited Düsseldorf, Germany, the capital of the German state North Rhine-Westphalia. While strolling along the river Rhine, I passed by “Villa Horion.” Villa Horion was built in 1910/11 by the German architect Hermann vom Endt in the neoclassical style. In 1984, it was registered as a historically protected building by the Department for the Preservation […]

Baseball Card Litigation: Fleer v. Topps

If you were not aware, the Library of Congress is the place for baseball cards.  Comprised of both donated collections and items deposited with the U.S. Copyright office, the Library’s collection is unparalleled (absent the elusive Honus Wagner card). You can view items from our collection in the Library’s Baseball Americana exhibition where cards are […]

Holy Cow – Making Sense of Japanese Wagyu Cow Export Rules

The following is a guest post by Sayuri Umeda, a foreign law specialist who covers Japan and other countries in East and Southeast Asia. Sayuri has previously written posts for In Custodia Legis on various topics, including Japanese Criminal Legal System as Seen Through the Carlos Ghosn Case, Disciplining Judges for “Bad Tweets”, Engagement under Japanese Law and Imperial House Rules, Is the Sound of Children Actually Noise?, How […]