Posing (and Solving) Mysteries: Harris & Ewing Photographs Invite Detective Work

I’m constantly amazed and amused by photographs from the Harris & Ewing Collection and the range in the information that came with them, from the sublimely detailed–full of names and dates–to the barer-than-bare bones: no caption at all. Here’s an example that intrigues me, particularly with the model wagon(?) beside her on the desk.

NO CAPTION (photo of a woman at a desk). Photo by Harris & Ewing, between 1913 and 1917. //hdl.loc.gov/loc.pnp/hec.03553

NO CAPTION. Photo by Harris & Ewing, between 1913 and 1917. //hdl.loc.gov/loc.pnp/hec.03553

Though some may find it confounding, if you like pursuing mysteries, the absence of information can be tantalizing. It invites all the satisfactions of detective work: deduction and deep dives into information sources documenting the era in which the photos were produced–a rather expansive 1905-1945.

Reference librarian Jon Eaker has been making his way systematically through the more than 41,000 digitized Harris & Ewing negatives, looking for those where the information might be enhanced. In the process, he has shared some great photos and has, simultaneously, demonstrated how he is able to piece together the story behind an unidentified photo. He recently shared this photo on the electronic version of our staff sharing wall.

Crowd viewing parade, Washington, D.C. Photo by Harris & Ewing, 1919. //hdl.loc.gov/loc.pnp/hec.41350

Crowd viewing parade, Washington, D.C. Photo by Harris & Ewing, 1919. //hdl.loc.gov/loc.pnp/hec.41350

When one of our colleagues asked if he knew what the group was watching, Jon laid out what he had figured out: “From the neighboring photos, I think it is people trying to view the Sept. 17th, 1919 parade that welcomed Pershing and the 1st Division back to Washington after WWI. In some of the neighboring photos you can see the temporary triumphal arch that was built just before the parade. The parade appears to be military in nature and no one is wearing coats. So I’m 95% certain it is that parade.” He also speculated that someone better versed in Washington, D.C., buildings might be able to figure out the precise location. For that we turned to our resident expert at deducing locations, reference specialist Kristi Finefield.  It didn’t take her long to come up with an answer: “They are standing on 14th Street NW, looking south toward the Mall and looking across Pennsylvania Ave. The arch Jon is referring to would have been a block to the right of the photo on Pennsylvania Ave.”

If you’re looking for an opportunity to exercise your own photo detecting skills, Jon has obliged by picking out some minimally-identified photos that we are featuring in our Flickr album, “Mystery Photos–What’s the Story?” (which also has lingering mysteries from previous years that remain to be resolved!).

There, you’ll see, for instance, this one that may hold some scientific or technology clues:

Laboratory? Photo by Harris & Ewing, 1927 or 1928. //hdl.loc.gov/loc.pnp/hec.34743

Laboratory? Photo by Harris & Ewing, 1927 or 1928. //hdl.loc.gov/loc.pnp/hec.34743

Here we know the location and even the year, but what are the horse and rider doing there?

Person on rearing horse in front of U.S. Capitol, Washington, D.C., 1927. //hdl.loc.gov/loc.pnp/hec.34612

Person on rearing horse in front of U.S. Capitol, Washington, D.C., 1927. //hdl.loc.gov/loc.pnp/hec.34612

And this one shows a pretty good portrait likeness, but we’d sure like to know more about Sara, which is all we could make out from the identification that came with the negative:

 Sara [..] Photo by Harris & Ewing, ca. 1938. //hdl.loc.gov/loc.pnp/hec.24864

Sara [..] Photo by Harris & Ewing, ca. 1938. //hdl.loc.gov/loc.pnp/hec.24864

If you think you know more about any of the photos above, please feel free to comment!

Learn More:

A Harvest of Pictures: New Flickr Albums

While many Prints & Photographs Division staff are working separately from their home offices, dens, and living rooms, pictures never fail to bring us together. In the waning days of summer, it’s a pleasure to immerse ourselves in the pictures that we gathered in response to seek-and-find challenges offered by reference specialist Jan Grenci. We […]

A Visual Salute to Nurses

The following is a guest post by Karen Chittenden, Cataloging Specialist in the Prints & Photographs Division. National Nurses Week recognizes the contributions of professional nurses, and this year we’d like to do the same by highlighting recently acquired photographs of wartime nurses who marshaled resources, medical skill, and courage to offer help in dire […]

Celebrating Eleven Years in the Flickr Commons

Eleven years ago today we posted our first sets of photos in the Flickr Commons, which was created to share treasures from the world’s public archives. Thousands of pictures, views, and comments later, we’re celebrating with a new album of pictures with an “eleven-ish” connection and an invitation to participate in a tagging activity in […]

Calling All Photo Fans & History Detectives: Flickr Commons, 10th Anniversary

The following is a guest post by Helena Zinkham, Chief, Prints & Photographs Division. It’s a remarkable achievement for any social media program to still be going strong after ten years. But the most important part of the Flickr Commons is the opportunity to talk about pictures without the barriers of time and place. A […]

On the Road Again: Scouting Out “Roadside America” Sites

When John Margolies gave a talk at the Library of Congress in 2011 about his project to photograph roadside attractions and commercial vistas all across America, he remarked, “If anybody knows if these places still exist, tell me later ’cause that’s very often the only way that I find out whether things are there anymore.” […]

Another Happy Anniversary Toast to the Flickr Commons!

Nine years ago this month, the Library of Congress, after much planning and discussion, loaded photos for the first time to Flickr and began an extended, gratifying exchange with picture lovers all over the world. That first upload put the Library’s pictures in front of a community whose members enjoy looking closely, appreciating fully, and […]

“What’s this Gadget?”: Solving Mystery Photos

We asked “What’s this Gadget?” about a set of twenty-five uncaptioned photographs from the Harris & Ewing Collection, and you definitely put on your thinking caps – or maybe your psychographs – which we learned the smiling woman below is “wearing”! This previously uncaptioned photograph shows a psychograph, a phrenology machine meant to measure the […]