Sergeants Robert A. Pinn and William H. Thomas: African American Entrants in William O. Bourne’s Left-Handed Penmanship Contests, 1865-1867

This post was written by Paul LaRue, a retired social studies teacher in Washington Court House, Ohio.

Most teachers appreciate good penmanship, or at least legible handwriting, and the Library of Congress holds the collection of one of the most fascinating penmanship contests in United States history. The human cost of the American Civil War was unprecedented, and newspaper editor William O. Bourne wanted to do something for disabled veterans.  According to the National Institute of Health, there were approximately 60,000 amputations performed on Civil War soldiers and sailors. In 1866, Bourne organized a unique left-handed penmanship contest for Union veterans who had lost the use of their right hand. Veterans were encouraged to submit a letter they had written using their left hand and a total prize money of $1000.00 was offered. The Library of Congress holds the many of the entrants’ letters and other information on Bourne and the contest.

Information about William Oland Bourne’s Left-Handed Penmanship contests, 1865-1867

The rules of the contest specified that the letters:

  • be two to seven pages in length,
  • have a patriotic theme,
  • describe the entrant’s military service, and
  • list full name, rank, regiment, and company.

Approximately two hundred thousand African American soldiers and sailors served in the Union Army and Navy, sharing the hardships of Civil War service, including coming to terms with the physical injuries suffered in combat. Three hundred and eighty-three Union soldiers and sailors submitted letters in the contest, including two African American soldiers.

First Sergeant Robert A. Pinn and Sergeant William H. Thomas both served in the 5th Regiment United States Colored Infantry  (U.S.C.I.), and their letters give some insights into African American Civil War service.

First Sergeant Robert A. Pinn’s entry, Wm. Oland Bourne Papers: Left-hand Penmanship contest

Sergeant Will H. Thomas’s entry, Wm. Oland Bourne Papers: Left-hand Penmanship contest

 

Ask students to examine the first pages of the Pinn and Thomas letters, and then to read and transcribe the letters. One strategy to support students who are not comfortable reading cursive is to assign one paragraph from a letter to pairs of students, and then jigsaw with other pairs to read the full page. What do they notice about how each writer begins his letter? What do they wonder about the writer? As time allows, assign students to read additional pages of one or both letters. Invite your students to generate a list of the challenges African American Civil War soldiers faced, including the impact of their injuries.

As an extension, students might research combat injuries in the Civil War versus injuries from current wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. Students might also research the lives of First Sergeant Robert A. Pinn and Sergeant William H. Thomas. One soldier was a Medal of Honor recipient, the other soldier became a controversial author following the Civil War. African American History Month provides students an opportunity to study the service, sacrifice, and contributions of African American Civil War soldiers.

Share your students’ discoveries in the comments!

One Comment

  1. Libby O’Connell
    February 28, 2019 at 8:41 am

    This is a fascinating source for many reasons. Thank you for sharing this. And do we know who won the $100,000? I wonder what happened to him.

Add a Comment

This blog is governed by the general rules of respectful civil discourse. You are fully responsible for everything that you post. The content of all comments is released into the public domain unless clearly stated otherwise. The Library of Congress does not control the content posted. Nevertheless, the Library of Congress may monitor any user-generated content as it chooses and reserves the right to remove content for any reason whatever, without consent. Gratuitous links to sites are viewed as spam and may result in removed comments. We further reserve the right, in our sole discretion, to remove a user's privilege to post content on the Library site. Read our Comment and Posting Policy.

Required fields are indicated with an * asterisk.