Where Do You Go If You’ve Reached a Historical “Dead End”?

This is a guest post by Elizabeth Lindqwister, the 2019 Family Fellow for the Liljenquist Collection of Civil War Photography at the Library of Congress. Elizabeth is an undergraduate student at Stanford University and will be working with the collection and the Library’s Prints and Photographs division for the summer.

I don’t believe in dead ends. A cul-de-sac is just a looping point, a retirement is a new beginning, running out of time is finding time for something else. And a Civil War nurse identified only by name and location? Well, that’s an opportunity.

When I started looking into nurse Cynthia Denham, I realized I had very little information. The carte-de-visite we have is not very telling, showing only a small image of her face in a distant yet pleased expression. Even when flipping the image over to look at the verso, I found just a name, a town, and the hospital she worked at – that was it.

Portrait of Cynthia R. Tuell Denham, a Rhode Island nurse who served at Lovell General Hospital during the Civil War. Joshua Appleby Williams

Verso, Portrait of Cynthia R. Tuell Denham, a Rhode Island nurse

 

So where can you look if you think you’ve run out of information about a person or place? How can we encourage students to be persistent researching in the face of a “dead end”? And how do we equip students with the knowledge of databases and archives, so that when they run into a historical dead end, they know where to keep looking?

It would seem that I reached a historical dead end with Cynthia Denham. But the image verso gave me just enough information, and I knew that there was more to be found about this nurse than what a simple online search would turn up.

Shuffling through files at the National Archives and Records Administration, I located a pension file application for Cynthia, and within minutes I was looking at the papers she submitted in 1896.

Lovell General Hospital, situated right on the water of Portsmouth Grove. The hospital was transformed out of the Portsmouth Grove Estate, when the mounting injuries from war demanded more extensive medical care. Joshua Appleby Williams

From this information, I was able to construct the life around her. Pension records gave faces to a family I had only guessed about previously; letters described her strenuous work at Lovell General Hospital; her personal notes were signed with a shaky hand that exposed Cynthia’s later-life health issues.

The Library’s collections were crucial in further situating Cynthia’s life in Civil War history, and images from the Prints and Photographs Division gave a realness to the wartime life she held and illustrated the places and people she likely engaged with. For example, this image of Portsmouth Grove shows the very hospital she worked at for the majority of the war, where Cynthia may have tended to upwards of 100 soldiers daily.

This image was a perfect springboard for me to find information about the other nurses, surgeons, and soldiers who passed through Rhode Island. Katharine Prescott Wormeley, another Liljenquist Collection nurse, was Superintendent of Lovell and might have been an acquaintance of Cynthia’s. Cynthia may have worked with Surgeon William F. McCormick, who also served at Lovell during the war.

Anna Maria Ross, Civil War nurse and Lady Principal at Cooper Shop Hospital, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. This photograph was taken the year of her death, in 1863. Moses S. Hagaman

And her husband, Daniel Denham, was enlisted in a regiment that passed through Cooper Shop Volunteer Refreshment Saloon and Hospital – the very same Cooper Shop Hospital that fellow nurse Anna Maria Ross helped found. This research created a cohesive narrative for one woman, while further connecting seemingly unrelated photos in the Liljenquist Collection.

Finding a single nib of information can lead to millions of other related gems buried in archives. When faced with a historical dead end, I sought alternative routes. A lack of information is an open invitation to creative research. So look to the Library’s photographs, maps, or manuscripts – chances are, there’s something there.

Leave us a comment about how you incorporate visual and textual items to deepen student understanding of history!

 

3 Comments

  1. Tom Bober
    August 21, 2019 at 9:58 am

    I was enticed in by the title of the newest Teaching with the Library of Congress Blog post. If you’ve worked with primary sources long enough, it has probably happened to you. This post from Elizabeth Lindqwister provides a fascination example of how you can push through a roadblock that looks like a dead end.

    I specifically noticed a few key things from her example:

    A thorough analysis of the historical document
    Being open to asking a wide array of questions (and while it is not said, maybe even ones that were initially unanticipated)
    Searching across multiple institutions in search of more information
    The use of a variety of formats to help to tell a story

    Thinking of myself as an educator who supports students in this process, what role do I play in that process? Initial thoughts are that of:

    A person who models all parts of this process above
    A bridge to primary sources where I assist students in finding resources to answer questions and this looks different with different students based on their age and experience.
    A thinking partner to assist students in externally sharing their struggles as they internalize a process
    A teacher who plans learning experiences that are not neat and tidy where students can hit what they perceive to be dead ends but where I can (sometimes) anticipate those to keep the learning moving forward.

  2. Rachelle Warren, Ed.D.
    August 21, 2019 at 6:09 pm

    Dear Ms. Danna Bell:

    I love the content of this article! When you mentioned the information listed on the reverse side of Ms. Denham’s photo, I knew immediately that you had other avenues for finding more research about this lady. In addition, your opening paragraph about “not believing in dead ends …” is great. Keep up the good work with your research.

    Sincerely,

    Rachelle Warren, Ed.D.

    rw

  3. Danna Bell
    August 22, 2019 at 10:31 am

    Thanks but if you look at the top of the post you will see that the author was Elizabeth Lindqwister, the 2019 Family Fellow for the Liljenquist Collection of Civil War Photography at the Library of Congress. I’m sure she will appreciate your compliments.

Add a Comment

This blog is governed by the general rules of respectful civil discourse. You are fully responsible for everything that you post. The content of all comments is released into the public domain unless clearly stated otherwise. The Library of Congress does not control the content posted. Nevertheless, the Library of Congress may monitor any user-generated content as it chooses and reserves the right to remove content for any reason whatever, without consent. Gratuitous links to sites are viewed as spam and may result in removed comments. We further reserve the right, in our sole discretion, to remove a user's privilege to post content on the Library site. Read our Comment and Posting Policy.

Required fields are indicated with an * asterisk.