{ subscribe_url: '/share/sites/library-of-congress-blogs/law.php' }

Drawing Justice Gallery Talk on Legal Research – Pic of the Week

Margaret Wood conducts a gallery tour of the exhibition, Drawing Justice, on June 21, 2017. Photo by Kimberly Allen.

Margaret Wood conducts a gallery tour of the exhibition, “Drawing Justice: The Art of Courtroom Illustration,” on June 21, 2017. Photo by Kimberly Allen.

Last week, I had the honor to give a gallery talk on the Library of Congress exhibit, Drawing Justice: The Art of Courtroom Illustration.  As a co-curator for the exhibit, I had helped in doing legal research for information about the cases portrayed by the drawings in the exhibit.  At the talk, I spoke about the challenge of doing legal research for state and federal trial court cases.  Very few of the opinions from trial courts are published.  Locating information for many of these cases was difficult and in many instances the best source of information was an appeals court decision on a case.  Many of the appellate court decisions I found provide a rich trove of information about the trial court case with a detailed exposition of the issues.  The other challenge in doing legal research for this exhibit was that I only used free online resources.  Luckily, in the last several years there has been an explosion of websites that provide access to published court decisions: Justia, Findlaw, Google Scholar, the Public Library of Law, and Casetext to name a few.

Using these resources, I spoke about three of the items in the exhibit for which I was able to find information.  The first drawing was a New York state criminal case, People v. Guzman.  It involved a pretrial issue as to whether Alex Naiman who was deaf was qualified to be a potential juror.  The judge’s decision, 478 NYS2d 455 (1984) ruled in Naiman’s favor.  The decision also used this opportunity to educate people about changes in the New York court rules that allowed deaf people in the jury pool.

One of the other drawings I spoke about was a drawing of the Bamboo Union trial.  In this situation, we had the appellate court decision, United States v. Chang An-Lo, aka White Wolf, 851 F.2d 547 (1988), that provided detailed information about a Chinese criminal syndicate which operated in several countries and committed crimes ranging from drug smuggling to the murder of a journalist, and which was brought down in part by an undercover agent.  The first few paragraphs of the court’s decision alone would provide a basis for an exciting movie script.

The third drawing involved one of several actions between Jackie Onassis and the photographer Ron Galella.  In this 1982 decision, Galella v. Onassis, 533 F.Supp. 1076 (S.D.N.Y.), the judge was ruling on the question as to whether Galella had violated the court’s 1975 order governing his interactions with Mrs. Onassis.  As part of the decision, the judge traced the court interactions, charges and countercharges between the two parties over a 12 year period, providing a detailed narrative.  As is often the situation, the decision was not just a dry legal ruling but a story about two protagonists.

Sara W. Duke, co-curator at the exhibition, was also at this talk, and helped with questions about the exhibit, providing information about the courtroom drawing collections at the Prints & Photographs Division as well as the relationships between courtroom illustrators and the news outlets that employ them.

The Drawing Justice exhibit will continue through the fall and we will return with additional gallery talks in September and October.  The exhibit can also be viewed online for those not in the Washington, D.C. area but if you are coming to our nation’s capital this summer, we hope you will visit the Library of  Congress and all our exhibits!

An Interview with Alia Hussain, Collections Technician

This week’s interview is with Alia Hussain, the newest technician in the Collection Services Division.  With her writing background, I’m hoping she decides to contribute to our blog. Describe your background. I was born and raised in New Jersey, then moved to Chicago after graduating high school to attend college. What is your academic/professional history? […]

Symposium on Rights and Resistance: Civil Liberties During Wartime

On Thursday, June 8, the Manuscripts Division in association with the Law Library sponsored a symposium examining the effects of World War I on civil liberties in the United States. Mary Dudziak, of Emory University, provided a historical overview of how Woodrow Wilson went from being reelected as the peace candidate- to in April 1917, requesting a […]

A Guide to Researching EU Law

The following is a guest post by Micaela DelMonte, a lawyer from the European Parliamentary Research Service who volunteered at the Law Library of Congress during May 2017. News about Brexit and the so-called Article 50 procedure have dominated the news about the European Union (EU) lately. If you are interested in researching these or […]

An Engraving of The First European Settlement in Florida, Fort Caroline – Pic of the Week

This post is coauthored by Nathan Dorn, rare book curator, and Robert Brammer, senior legal information specialist. Our picture of the week is an image of Fort Caroline, Florida, which was founded by French Huguenots on June 22nd of 1564. This print has a complicated, but interesting history. It is part of a 1591 imprint of Theodor de […]

International Tribunals Web Archive Launched

International tribunals have been around for some time, but the creation of international courts and tribunals to deal with international crimes is a relatively recent occurrence, with the first international criminal tribunal established just after World War II. The Max Planck Encyclopedia of Public International Law defines “international courts and tribunals” as ”permanent judicial bodies made up of independent […]

Proxy Voting in France

The following is a guest post from Nicolas Boring, foreign law specialist covering French speaking jurisdictions at the Law Library of Congress. France has just finished its election season!  French citizens elected Emmanuel Macron as their new president earlier in May, and they returned to the voting booths on June 11 and June 18 for parliamentary […]