{ subscribe_url: '/share/sites/library-of-congress-blogs/law.php' }

John Ross: His Struggle for Homeland and Sovereignty

This post was co-authored by Jennifer Davis and Shannon Herlihy, Law Library Creative Intern.

Saturday, October 3, was the birthday of Principal Chief John Ross (ᎫᏫᏍᎫᏫ) a member of the Cherokee Nation, of Cherokee and Scottish descent, who through his tribal leadership guided the Cherokee people through multiple legal challenges.

[John Ross, full length portrait, facing front standing next to a small table] Ross was principal chief of the Cherokee Nation, 1828-1866 Library of Congress Prints & Photographs Division //hdl.loc.gov/loc.pnp/cph.3g11120 

Ross was educated at mission schools and private boarding schools, and followed Cherokee traditions. He could speak and write well in Tsalagi and English, and by 1810 he was already serving his community by acting as an Indian agent for the Cherokee people on behalf of the United States.  Soon after, Ross served as a military officer in the War of 1812. After the war, he was elected to the newfound Cherokee National Council, acting as the primary English-speaking member of the tribe to communicate their needs to representatives of the United States government. In 1819, Ross was named President of the National Committee (lower house of the Cherokee government) as he discussed his tribe’s inherited rights to Cherokee land with an acquisitive U.S. government (Inskeep, 97).

The Compact of 1802 had been established 16 years prior to Ross’s appointment as the President of the National Committee. The compact agreed that Georgia would give up all rights to lands to the west and the federal government would remove Cherokee, Mvskoke and other indigenous peoples from their ancestral lands. Between 1805 and 1833, Georgia held eight lotteries to give away traditional Cherokee lands to whites.

Prominent members of Cherokee leadership, including John Ross, Major Ridge, and John Ridge, worked in various ways to try to stop the planned destruction of the Cherokee homelands. First, the Cherokee Council, including John Ross, adopted their first constitution in 1827, establishing executive, legislative, and judicial branches of their government. At the time, Pathkiller was Principal Chief, but shortly afterward, in 1828, Pathkiller died, and two weeks later his second in command Charles Hicks died, and John Ross was elected Principal Chief.

For the next ten years, Ross fought in the courts, and tried diplomacy with leaders in Washington, D.C., to no avail. After the Indian Removal Act passed in May 1830, Ross and the Cherokee people hired former Attorney General William Wirt. Wirt wrote his Opinion on the Right of the State of Georgia to Extend Her Laws Over the Cherokee Nation, in which he argued that the Cherokee people should be considered a sovereign nation under the U.S. Constitution. Wirt represented the Cherokee in the 1831 U.S. court case, Cherokee Nation v. Georgia. Wirt and Ross argued that previous Cherokee treaties and Cherokee Nation sovereignty had been violated through the enactment of Georgia’s new laws. The court did not rule for Cherokee Nation; the court considered that Cherokee Nation was not a foreign nation and, thus, the court would not hear its complaints against Georgia.

In 1835, while he was in D.C. and the Senate was offering Ross $5 million for the tribe to sell around 7 million acres, a posse called the Georgia Guard took his house (Inskeep, 208). The Georgia Guard also seized the printing press of the Cherokee Phoenix at New Echota in August 1835 and briefly took Ross prisoner in November (Inskeep, 208).

Shortly afterward, while Ross was traveling again to D.C., Major Ridge, John Ridge and a few others signed the Treaty of New Echota on December 29, 1835, accepting $5 million, minus various costs which the United States government charged the Cherokee government (Inskeep, 212). The Treaty Party, as the Ridges’ group came to be called, were a small minority of the tribe’s members and not authorized to sign on behalf of the Cherokee. Ridge seems to have acted because he thought it would save lives; he also got financial compensation for his substantial properties (Inskeep, 212). He and his son believed that signing the treaty without the tribe’s consent would probably cost them their lives, and in fact they were correct.

The Cherokee removal started in 1836, when Ridge and his cohort were marched out of Georgia, Alabama, and other parts of the Cherokee homelands to Indian Territory. Many Cherokee remained in their homelands, while the U.S. government worked to remove them. The United States government marched approximately 16,000 Cherokees in September or October from their homelands to Indian Territory. They left just before one of the worst winters on record. On the trip, one estimate found that one in four Cherokees died; another estimate determined that the Cherokee population “may have been reduced by as many as eight thousand from what it otherwise would have been” (Inskeep, 236). It is unknown how many more died from the journey once they reached their destination 950 miles and six months later; it is now known as the Trail of Tears. The final detachment, composed of the elderly, ill and lame, left in December 1838, after a previous 13 detachments of a thousand people each (Moulton, 99-100).

After the Cherokee started to settle in their new land, they argued with the federal government for years about their remuneration for the trip which the Treaty of New Echota guaranteed (Moulton, 101-104); their claim was not settled until 1841. John Ross worked to keep the Cherokee people united and was instrumental in the passage of their new constitution in 1839. He struggled for years save his people’s lands and their sovereignty and although they suffered many hardships, Ross and the Cherokee people succeeded in their ultimate goal: they are still here.

Sources

E382.I57 2015 Inskeep, Steve. Jacksonland: President Andrew Jackson, Cherokee Chief John Ross, and a great American land grab. (2015)

E99.C5 R675 Moulton, Gary E. John Ross, Cherokee Chief. (1978)

Nagle, Rebecca. The Treaty. [podcast] This Land, June 24, 2019. [Accessed 28 September 2020].

Indigenous Law Portal: Oklahoma

Federal government apology for treatment of Indigenous peoples, Pub. L. No. 111-118, § 8113 (a) (2009).

KIG2000.5.A3 1827 Cherokee Nation, Oklahoma. Constitution of the Cherokee nation, made and established at a general convention of delegates, duly authorised for that purpose, at New Echota, July 26, 1827.

Jackson, Andrew, and John Ross Et Al. J. Ross et al. to Andrew Jackson. 1835. Manuscript/Mixed Material.

KIG2000.5 .A3 1827 Cherokee Nation, Oklahoma. Cherokee laws. Enacted by the General Council, of the Cherokees residing in the direction of the east; passed from time to time at the Council ground: beginning in the year 1808. And also the laws enacted by the Cherokees known as the “Old settlers” residing in the direction of the west. Beginning in the year 1824. Together with the laws of the United Cherokees formerly residing in the direction of the east and west. And also the constitution and laws here enacted; beginning with the year 1839 and continuing to 1849. Printed by order of the General council. Tsunitsutlâhitû, interpreter. Damaga publisher.

KIG2006 .C44 1840  Cherokee Nation, Oklahoma. The constitution and laws of the Cherokee Nation:  passed at Tah-le-quah, Cherokee nation, 1839.

 

From the Serial Set: Citizenship and Suffrage for Native Americans

Welcome to the final installment of suffrage stories from the Serial Set! Today, we will be looking at the history of Native American citizenship and how voting rights came into play. Despite the ratification of the 15th Amendment in 1870, Native Americans were not guaranteed citizenship, nor voting rights, under the United States government. Reports from the […]

The Teaching Contract that Brought Sami Reindeer to Alaska

Today marks the National Sami Day in Sapmi – an area spanning the national borders of northern Norway, Sweden, Finland and Russian Kola Peninsula. The Sami are a semi-nomadic people who have moved across national borders in Sapmi for hundreds of years. Similar to other people from the Scandinavian countries, they have also crossed the Atlantic in hopes […]

Chief Standing Bear and His Landmark Civil Rights Case

The National Statuary Hall of the United States Capitol has a number of statues of indigenous Americans—Will Rogers, Kamehameha I, Washakie, Po’pay, Sequoyah, Sakakawea, and the newest—Chief Standing Bear, just donated to the hall by Nebraska and installed in September 2019. If a legal scholar wanted to study an inspiring legal figure for Native American […]

Remembering the Ancestors for Indigenous People’s Day

Greetings from Piscataway/Pamunkey lands! As Indigenous Peoples Day approached, the blog team discussed writing about the holiday and a new program that is going to air soon. It seemed like a good time to remember some of the earlier residents of this country: the Ancestral Puebloans. Conservators have worked to preserve many of their dwellings in […]

The Murder of Penowanyanquis and the Trial of Arthur Peach, Plymouth, 1638

One of the most vivid criminal trials of seventeenth-century American history celebrated its 380th anniversary a few days ago on Sept. 4. On that day, in 1638, authorities in Plymouth Colony tried Arthur Peach, along with three codefendants, for the murder of a Nipmuc man called Penowanyanquis. The court found the men guilty and sentenced […]